2015 GAME OF THE YEAR IS IN THE BAG. If you want to listen to the show look for episode 111 in the podcast list.
Here is a list of each presenter's choices from five to number one.
Jim - Mario Kart 8 / Monument Valley / Destiny / Hearthstone / Titanfall
Fish - Bayonetta 2 / Hearthstone / Alien Isolation / Talos Principle / Wolfenstein
Dave - Evil Within / Wolfenstein / Titanfall / Talos Principle / Shadow of Mordor
Jon - Monument Valley & Framed..WTF? / Hearthstone / Shadow of Mordor / Destiny / Diablo III
Fraser - Wolf Among Us / Shadow of Mordor / Wolfenstein / Hearthstone / Rust
Steve - Wolfenstein / Alien Isolation / Mario Kart 8 / Shadow of Mordor / Destiny
So, if we give reverse points (five for 1st, four for 2nd etc..), our joint top 5 (actually 6) looks like this.....
Joint 6th & 5th - Titanfall & The Talos Principle
4th - Wolfenstein The New Order
Joint 3rd & 2nd - Destiny & Hearthstone
1ST - Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor
so there you go...again..